Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream, & a Giveaway!

A Step-by-Step Picture Tutorial on How to Make Perfect Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream.  This Simple Recipe will be your Basic Go-to for making Classic Churned Ice Cream.

Don’t forget to scroll all the way to the bottom of the post for a fabulous giveaway from Nielsen Massey!

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

Hello dear friends!  I hope you had a wonderful weekend!  Mine was pretty low-key and relaxing.  I’ve caught up on things over the last week, thanks in part to my good friend Lisa and her Key Lime Pie Posset recipe from Friday (Did you see it?  Please do check it out!).

And I’ve even been able to get on top of a few organizational things around the house that have been making me twitchy for months.  I don’t think I’ve ever shared this with you guys before, and maybe you won’t be too surprised to know, but I’m kind of an organization junkie.  When things aren’t “just so,” it kinda makes me nuts.  With two little boys I’m sure you can imagine I feel nuts a lot of the time!  But I love reading décor blogs and organizing blogs because they are so inspiring!

Hall Bath Before Collage

I have some friends coming to stay at my house in a few weeks, and I’m working on getting our guest bedroom/bathroom situation in order before they arrive.  This is a house project that’s been on the back burner for months (years even?) so I’m really happy for the incentive to finally get it done!  I’m sharing a photo of the current state of affairs in our hall/kids bathroom, in hopes of showing the final, made-over result after I finish tidying, improving, and beautifying!

But today’s post is all about vanilla.  I’m thrilled to be able to offer a fabulous prize package of Neilsen Massey vanilla products at the end of this post, so be sure to scroll all the way to the bottom to get your entries in!

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

I thought long and hard about what kind of vanilla recipe to include with this giveaway, but at the end of the day there was really no other option.  We’re smack in the middle of the hazy-hot-and-humid-est time of the year, and what really showcases the rich and delicate flavor of vanilla better than ice cream???  Ok well there’s cupcakes but that’s already been covered.  😉

The idea of making homemade, classic churned ice cream might seem a little intimidating, with separating and tempering the eggs and all, but I’m here to tell you: you can totally do this.  Plan ahead and take your time and you’ll be golden.  And your efforts will be so rewarded, when you taste the amazingly rich, creamy, and flavorful result.

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

It all begins with egg yolks, sugar and salt.  Place them together in a bowl and whisk.

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

Now heat a bit of milk on the stove until there are wisps of steam rising from the top and little bubbles forming around the edges.

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

Pour the hot milk into the eggs, a little at a time, while whisking.  Once all the hot milk has been added, you’ll notice the mixture feels very warm to the touch.  That is good!  You’ve tempered the yolks, and now the mixture can go back on the stove.  It’s much less likely to curdle now, because of the tempering, but keep the heat low and whisk continuously as it cooks, just to be safe.  When it feels hot and looks thickened…

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

…remove it from the heat and strain it into a heat safe bowl.  At this point, all you have to do is add the cream and vanilla!

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

I really love Nielsen Massey vanilla bean paste, and they are not paying me to say that!  I have loved it for years, mainly because of the intense vanilla punch it packs, and those little specks of vanilla bean seeds.  You can get the same effect with a whole bean, but it’s much, much more expensive.  Nielsen Massey vanilla bean paste is a lot more economical, and it keeps in the cupboard for a long time.  I highly recommend it!  You can order it online through my shop by clicking here.  (Please note that this is an affiliate link, so I make a small commission from your purchase.)

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

Chill the custard overnight in the fridge, and freeze the canister of your ice cream maker.  This is the ice cream maker I’m currently in love with.  <–That is not an affiliate link.  I love this ice cream maker attachment because it takes up so much less space than a standalone machine, and it works beautifully.

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

In the morning you can churn your ice cream, and transfer it to a loaf pan for easy scooping.  Ta-dah!

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment


Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream

This Simple Recipe will be your Basic Go-to for making Classic Churned Ice Cream.



  1. Chill the canister of an ice cream maker in the freezer overnight.
  2. Place the yolks, sugar, and salt in a medium bowl and whisk until pale and thick.
  3. Place the milk in a small pot and heat on the stove until small bubbles appear around the edges and wisps of steam are rising from the surface. Pour the hot milk into the yolk mixture, a little at a time, while whisking.
  4. When all of the hot milk has been incorporated, transfer the custard back to the pot and heat over medium-low, whisking, until hot and slightly thickened. Strain into a heat safe bowl, stir in the cream and vanilla, and chill overnight.
  5. Churn the ice cream for about 15-25 minutes, or until it resembles soft-serve ice cream. Transfer to a loaf pan and freeze until hard.

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

I think you will really love how rich and creamy this homemade vanilla ice cream is.  And it’s a great recipe to keep in your recipe box, as sort of a basic building block.  You can add all sorts of flavors or mix-ins, and really make it your own.  Enjoy!

And now for the giveaway!  I’m teaming up with some of my favorite bloggers to offer this fabulous prize pack from Nielsen Massey, valued at over $200:

2oz Pure Almond Extract
2oz Pure Chocolate Extract
2oz Pure Coffee Extract
2oz Pure Lemon Extract
2oz Pure Orange Extract
2oz Orange Blossom Water
2oz Pure Peppermint Extract
2oz Rose Water
2.5oz Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Powder
4oz Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract
4oz Organic Fairtrade Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract
4oz Tahitian Pure Vanilla Extract
4oz Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Bean Paste
8.5oz Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Sugar
2 bean vial, Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Beans
A Century of Flavor Cookbook

Good luck, and be sure to check out these other great vanilla treats by a few of my besties:

Vanilla Bean Ricotta Cheesecake Cake from Chez CateyLou
Funfetti Hi-Hat Cupcakes from bethcakes
Coconut Raspberry Rhubarb Ice Cream from Blahnik Baker
Snickerdoodle Caramel Tart from Club Narwhal
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream by URBAN BAKES

Simply Perfect Vanilla Ice Cream | Baking a Moment

Subscribe via RSS Follow on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Pinterest Follow on Google Plus Follow on BlogLovin' Follow on Instagram


  1. says

    I’ve made this custard based ice cream before Allie, and it is amazing and oh so worth it. People seem to get scared off because of the eggs, but really it is easy as long as you stay put and watch. :)

    Can’t beat vanilla ice cream, in my opinion, and loving the flecks of the vanilla bean paste.

  2. says

    Allie, I love this step by step! Making custard/egg-based ice cream has always intimidated me but maybe I will work up the gumption to finally try it since this looks SO amazing :) Also, I need your organization skills in a major way at my house…

  3. says

    I like how you mention this is a great base ice cream as well! Looks so creamy and amazing. Sometimes vanilla is all you need 😉 Also, I LOVE the photo with the ice cream cone in the mason car with the sprinkles? or beads? on the bottom, well done Allie! Looking forward to the final bathroom shots! Have a great Monday!

  4. blahnikbaker says

    I always love your simply perfect recipes!! This is another great great one to add to the archives. Love me vanilla ice cream any day :) Beautiful pictures!! Oh and I can’t wait to see the bathroom makeover…literally can’t wait 😉

  5. says

    I love the step by step instructions on here! And the final result is perfection – you really picked the right name! I could go for a giant cone right now! Oh and can’t wait to see your after bathroom pix, although the before looks pretty tidy to me!

    • says

      Thank you Cate! I guess it’s not to messy (if you ignore the toothpaste smears on the counter!) but I’m hoping to make it a little prettier. I’m looking forward to seeing it all come together. Thanks for the sweet compliments about my ice cream, and thank you again so much for putting the giveaway together!

  6. says

    haha I’m an organization junkie too so I totally appreciate that :) I’m always organizing and trying to come up with better systems / storage etc! lol

    Classic vanilla bean is my absolute favorite flavor – this looks amazing!

  7. says

    I always love your simply perfect recipes, Allie :) Vanilla is my all time favorite ice cream too and I love how creamy and fabulous this one looks :)
    Haha, I hear ya on the organization – my lil guy and husband can drive me bonkers with messing things up so I am always looking for better ways to organize. I can’t wait to see your bathroom makeover :)

  8. says

    Your ‘perfect’ recipes always do look perfect, Allie! I love this recipe and now of course want to buy an ice cream maker.
    Thanks so much for the step-by-step … it’s so appreciated as I’ve never attempted making my own ice cream.

    • says

      Lol sorry! Well if you have the room to store it I think you will enjoy having the ice cream maker. I have a lot of fun with mine, especially at this time of year. Thank you so much for the lovely compliments! xoxo

  9. says

    Sometimes (actually, most of the times), the simplest things are the ones that are enjoyed most! Like this vanilla ice cream! A simple flavor yet a classic and something that can never be replaced with anything else! This looks sooooo incredible Allie! Lovinggggg that pretty .gif and the step-by-step instructions make the custard base making process a real breeze! <3 Pinning! 😀

    • says

      Thank you so much Samina and I feel the same way! Sometimes I get so wrapped up in the process of making something new and unique that I forget how important (and delicious!) the simple basics can be. I’m so glad you feel me on that! Thanks for the sweet comment and the pin too 😉

    • says

      Oh Nora you are too sweet! Btw, the hubby was in Montreal all weekend long! I showed him your post so he could check out some of your recs- he’s bringing me home some bagels! Can’t wait to try 😉 Hope you had a fun weekend sweetie! xoxo

Leave a Reply