Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut cream pie: Coconutty vanilla-scented custard nestled into a toasty crust & crowned with billows of soft whipped cream. Truly amazing!
It’s coconut season!
Lol! I don’t know why I always associate this time of year with coconut, but somehow it works!
I have to be honest with you: I never really thought coconut cream pie could be something I’d really love. I’ve been iffy on coconut in general for most of my life, and something like this just never held a whole lot of appeal.
But that all changed after I tasted this coconut cream pie recipe!
It’s really a “wow” dish. All the components come together for a dessert that’s beautifully balanced, loaded with chewy coconut, and whisper-light yet completely satisfying!
I’m a convert!
If you’re someone who has always loved coconut, then you probably won’t need much convincing. This recipe is definitely worth making!
And you may also want to check out my coconut cake, my coconut bread, and my coconut macaroons!
Table of Contents
- What is coconut cream pie?
- Why this is the best coconut cream pie recipe
- What does coconut cream pie taste like?
- Ingredients
- Special equipment
- How to make coconut cream pie
- How to serve
- Expert tips
- Frequently asked questions
- A few more of my best pie recipes
What is coconut cream pie?
Coconut cream pie is a classic dessert that’s been around for generations.
It consists of a slightly sweet, eggy, vanilla-scented custard folded into shredded coconut and nestled into a toasty pie crust. It’s then topped with billows of whipped cream, and garnished with toasted coconut.
If you’re a coconut lover, this pie has your name written all over it!
Why this is the best coconut cream pie recipe
- Tastes amazing: I love how this pie isn’t overly sweet. There’s a really nice balance of flavors.
- Few ingredients: You’ll only need a handful of pantry staples to make it.
- Easy to make: Follow the steps one by one and you’ll have no trouble making it!
- Seasonal: Coconut desserts are great at any time of year, but they’re especially nice around Easter-time.
What does coconut cream pie taste like?
You’ll notice the light, airy sweetness right away. But it’s tempered by the toasty, slightly savory flavor of the pie crust.
And the filling is positively packed with chewy coconut!
There’s also the sweet aroma of vanilla and a rich, eggy quality of the custard itself.
Ingredients
Pie dough: A half batch of my incredibly flaky, buttery homemade pie crust will suit perfectly, or you can use store-bought dough or a premade crust if you’re on a time crunch. Use a cup for cup gluten-free flour blend and a plant-based butter substitute to make this gluten-free and dairy-free!
Yolks: Just the yolks from large chicken eggs, or a 1:1 plant-based substitute. You can either toss the whites or reserve them for another use (such as royal icing, s’mores brownies, or Key lime cake).
Sugar: You’ll need granulated white sugar for the custard, plus a little bit of powdered sugar to sweeten the whipped cream on top.
Cornstarch: Cornstarch thickens the filling. It’s a colorless, odorless, flavorless starch. Make sure you’re using cornstarch, which is white and powdery, and not cornmeal, which is yellow and gritty and tastes like tortilla chips.
Salt: Salt balances the flavors and intensifies them. The end result won’t taste salty, just more flavorful. I like kosher salt best because it doesn’t have any bitter-tasting additives (like iodized table salt), plus it’s cheap and easy to find in the regular grocery store.
Milk: Use whatever kind you have on hand. I especially love to use coconut milk for this recipe. You could also use cream of coconut. Just check the label, if it’s sweetened you’ll want to omit the granulated sugar.
Vanilla: Vanilla extract adds a sweet perfume that compliments the coconut flavor.
Cream: Heavy whipping cream goes into the topping. Make sure you’re using full-fat heavy cream. If you’re not in the US this product may be called “double cream.” Half and half won’t work, and neither will light cream. You need that high fat content for it to whip up properly. For a dairy-free option, whip the solidified cream that rises to the top of the can of coconut milk.
Special equipment
- Measuring cups and spoons: Follow my instructions on how to measure ingredients.
- Mixing bowl
- Whisk: To ensure a lump-free custard.
- Pot: In which to cook the filling.
- Silicone spatula: For folding everything together and for getting the last bit out of the bowl!
- Rolling pin: With which to roll out the crust.
- Fork: To dock the crust so it doesn’t poof up in the middle as it bakes.
- Pie dish: A standard-sized pie dish (Not deep dish!), metal, glass, or stoneware will work.
- Mixer: I like to use an electric mixer to whip the cream, but you can do this by hand if you’ve got strong arms!
- Skillet: In which to toast the coconut flakes.
How to make coconut cream pie
This easy recipe comes together in just 4 simple steps.
Step 1: Blind-bake the crust
Roll the pie dough out to an inch or so larger in diameter than your pie dish.
Then ease it in, turn the edges under, and crimp. If you want to see how this is done, check out the video on this post: Homemade Pie Crust.
Next, take a fork and prick little holes all over the bottom of the crust.
This is called “docking” the dough, and it helps ensure that hot air doesn’t collect underneath and expand, creating a big bubble instead of a flat base.
Scrunch up a piece of parchment paper, then flatten it back out and slip it into the unbaked crust. Place ceramic pie weights or dry beans on top to keep everything where it should be.
Blind-bake the crust in a preheated oven until it’s nicely browned.
Step 2: Make the coconut custard
Start by placing the egg yolks, sugar, cornstarch, and salt in a big bowl.
Whisk them together until smooth, then dribble in hot milk, just a little bit at a time.
You can heat the cream in the microwave or in a pot on the stove. You just want it steamy, it doesn’t have to be boiling.
Once all the hot milk has been whisked in, transfer the mixture to a pot and place it on the stove over medium-low heat.
Cook the custard, whisking constantly, until it thickens up. The amount of time this takes can vary based on how many btu’s your range has, but keep in mind that it won’t reach its full thickening potential until it comes to a simmer.
Then just fold the shredded coconut and vanilla into the pastry cream.
Step 3: Fill the pie
Transfer the coconut custard into the baked and cooled crust, smoothing it into an even layer.
Step 4: Garnish
Whip the heavy cream and powdered sugar together until the mixture can hold soft peaks.
Then top the pie with big clouds of whipped cream.
I also like to sprinkle on some toasted coconut chips.
These are more like big shards of desiccated coconut, whereas the shredded coconut in the filling is finer. I prefer the unsweetened kind, but sweetened works too.
You can toast the coconut flakes in a dry skillet over medium heat until they brown slightly and become fragrant. Or you can put them on a little baking sheet and toast them in a toaster oven. Just stick close by- they can burn quickly!
How to serve
Cut this pie into individual slices and serve it chilled or at room temperature.
It really doesn’t need a single thing, but a drizzle of chocolate syrup or salted caramel sauce could be really nice!
Expert tips
Toast the crust: I really like the flavor a deeply golden brown crust adds to this pie!
Don’t stop whisking: Whisk the custard constantly as it cooks, so you don’t get lumps of scrambled egg.
Let it cool: The custard will become even thicker as it comes down in temperature.
Don’t overwhip the cream: I love the look of soft billows of whipped cream. This can be hard to achieve if your whipped cream is too stiff. Aim for soft peaks.
Wipe the blade: For neat, clean slices of pie, give your knife blade a thorough wipe after each slice.
Frequently asked questions
If you don’t cook your custard long enough, it could come out runny. Make sure to bring it all the way up to a simmer, and whisk it constantly to avoid lumps.
You can use unsweetened OR sweetened coconut. It’s up to you!
Personally, I always prefer my desserts to be a little less sugary, so I used unsweetened shredded coconut.
The answer is yes! It’s a good idea to allow yourself plenty of extra time so the custard can cool.
And if you have any concern at all about a soggy crust, wait until the last minute to transfer the filling into the pre-baked pie crust.
As it sits, the whipped cream may lose a little of its volume. To prevent this, you may want to use my whipped cream frosting instead. It’s a bit more stable and less likely to collapse or weep.
This pie can be cut into 6 generous slices. The nutritional info below is for 1/6th of the whole pie, using sweetened shredded coconut in the filling and unsweetened toasted coconut chips on top.
A few more of my best pie recipes
As an amazon associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Coconut Cream Pie
Ingredients
- 1/2 batch (85 g) flaky homemade pie crust
- 6 (108 g) egg yolks, large
- 1/2 cup (100 g) granulated sugar
- 1/4 cup (32 g) cornstarch
- 1/2 teaspoon (3 g) kosher salt
- 1 1/2 cups (366 g) milk, any kind (I especially like unsweetened coconut milk)
- 7 ounces (198.45 g) shredded coconut, (sweetened OR unsweetened)
- 1 teaspoon (4 g) vanilla extract
- 1 1/2 cups (357 g) heavy whipping cream
- 2 1/2 tablespoons (20 g) powdered sugar
- 1/2 cup (42.5 g) coconut chips, toasted
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
- On a lightly floured surface, roll out the pie dough to an inch or two larger in diameter than your pie dish.
- Ease the dough into the dish, trim away any excess, roll the edges under, and crimp.
- Prick holes in the bottom of the unbaked crust with a fork, then line with parchment and pie weights or dry beans.
- Pre-bake the crust until it's golden brown and crisp (approx. 1 hour).
- Whisk the egg yolks, granulated sugar, cornstarch, and salt together in a large bowl.
- Heat the milk until steamy (in the microwave or in a small pot on the stove) and dribble it slowly into the egg mixture while whisking.
- When all the milk has been added, pour the mixture into a pot and cook over medium-low heat (whisking constantly) until thickened* (approx. 5 to 10 minutes).
- Fold the shredded coconut and vanilla into the custard, then press plastic wrap directly onto the surface of the coconut custard and chill for 2 hours.
- Transfer the chilled coconut custard to the pre-baked pie crust.
- Whip the cream and powdered sugar together until the mixture can hold soft peaks.
- Top the pie with whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes.
I have a thing for desserts in jars. They just make eating dessert even more fun! And Coconut Cream Pie is also my absolute favourite, so it’s pretty much assured I will be making these very shortly 🙂
Yay! I’m loving the desserts-in-jars thing lately too. So fun. Thanks so much for the sweet comment, Jennifer, and I hope you enjoy the recipe! 😀
They are so pretty! And I love that you made them in little jars. It saves the hassle of a pie crust!
Oh ya, totally! The crust doesn’t get much easier, just popped the cookies in the mini-chopper and sprinkled them in the jars. So glad you enjoyed, Mallory! <3
Coconut cream pie is my favorite! Love these individual ones!
I’m loving it lately too, Jessica! And this one is super coconutty with the coconut milk in the custard AND the whipped cream. So happy you like- thanks so much for reading and commenting!
Checked this out already on Mary Frances’ blog, Allie. I love that girl, too! She’s so so sweet!
It really is hard to believe this is both gluten and dairy free. Looks SO delicious!
Thanks Helen! I know, Mary Frances is just amazing- I just can’t get over that girl. Thanks so much for the sweet comment, love!
The sensitive tummies thing really caught my attention! These look lovely.
Thanks, Tashiana! I know that’s what Mary Frances’ readers probably look for, and it was easy enough with the coconut milk and gluten free cookies. So happy you liked! And thank you for the sweet comment 🙂
These are so adorable! My kids would love these in their own individual containers!
Oh, yeah! Perfect for kiddos, I hadn’t even thought of that! Thanks so much for popping over, Serena, and for commenting too 😀
I would love digging down to the crust with every scoop, this is awesome!
That’s just what we did, Matt! So glad you enjoyed, thanks for reading and commenting 😀
Gosh this is seriously gorgeous girl!!!! I am so in love with these! And dairy free??
Yep- 100%! Coconut milk, man. Makes my job easy 😉
These look amazing Allie! Love the fact they’re GF and Dairy free! Delicious recipe! 🙂
Thanks Jess! Mr. Allie was a happy man- it’s his favorite and he’s been begging me for it for YEARS!
omigosh AMAZING! They’re so pretty and cute and creamy and delicious-I cannot believe they’re gluten and DAIRY free!!!
Thank you so much, Kayle! You’re such a sweetheart. Hope you’re having a fun week, my dear!
Gorgeous and divine. You know my love for coconut. Gonna share this in a round up Allie. And pinned….of course.
Have a marvelous day!
Thanks so much for sharing Melanie! And yes, I do ;P
Love this recipe, Allie! I found you from Mary France’s blog (one of my faves) and love your blog, too! Such wonderful desserts!
Thank you so much, Gayle! I’m so happy you popped over and said hello! I hope to see you here again 😀
Thank you SO much Allie! You did a beautiful job with these. And you are too sweet to make them allergy friendly! The honor was completely mine and it is such a treat to have you post for me today! Thank you again!
I’m so glad you were happy with the guest post, Mary Frances! Thank you so much for the opportunity to post on The Sweet {Tooth} Life- I had a blast!
What a beautiful treat, Allie! And I love that it is GF and dairy free. I am always looking for desserts like this to make for friends with food allergies. Hopping over to Mary Frances to check out the deats 🙂
Thanks Amy! I hope you enjoy!
Allie, these are GORGEOUS!!! LOVE! heading over now to check out the recipe!
Thank you so much, Alice! I hope you enjoy the post <3
hi Allie so glad you made this recipe, however, i am confused by the ingredients calling for 1-12oz can of coconut milk but then has to be used in both the custard and the topping. is it a typo? or do i divide in half? i cant wait to try this recipe! warmly, Raz
Hi Raz! There is one room temperature can to be used in the filling and one cold can to be used for the topping. Hope that’s helpful!
These coconut cream pies are sooooo cute. They look so indulgent considering they are dairy free!
Thank you so much, Rochelle! I’m so glad you enjoyed the post! Thanks for reading and commenting 😀
Can the recipe for Coconut Cream Pies be made in a regular pie pan? And can at least the custard be made a day in advance and then assembled the next day for serving?
Hi Marie! You can definitely make the custard ahead- that is what I usually do just because it takes at least 2 hours to chill and firm up. I have not made this as a regular pie, so I’m not 100% sure if the quantity is right. I think it might not be quite enough filling, but that would depend on the size of your pie pan. It’s not dairy-free, but you might want to check out/modify this banana cream pie recipe: https://bakingamoment.com/banana-cream-pie/. Hope that’s helpful!
Thank you for getting back to me. I toasted the coconut, made the filling, crushed the cookies ahead. I used a Pyrex loaf pan and figured 4 small Gluten free sugar cookies per serving which turned out to be just about 2 TBS per 6-6oz portions from this size dish. It does not slice smoothly of course with the custard still a little soft and the crumbs not a hard, firm crust, but I used a narrow spatula and lifted each portion out.
I mistakenly used Light Coconut Milk. It worked fine in the custard, but did not separate out the water at the top as instructed, nor whip. I just left the topping off, and just garnished the top of the pudding with the toasted coconut.
I am confused that you state this recipe is not Dairy Free?? Title states otherwise. Are you counting butter?? The cookies are non dairy and so is the Coconut Milk. A
The dessert was well received by GFDF person and others. Thank you. M. Hise
Hey Marie! It sounds like you did a good job making it work. I was referencing the banana cream pie recipe I shared with you, when I said it was not dairy free. The banana cream pie filling I linked to is lighted with whipped cream.